The Offer’s Lower Than You Hoped—Now What? How to Negotiate Salary Like a Pro (Without Losing the Job)

You’ve made it to the final round, impressed everyone on the panel, and now... the offer’s in. But it’s lower than expected.

If your stomach dropped, you’re not alone. Salary negotiations are one of the most nerve-wracking parts of the job search process—especially when you're unsure how much room there is to push back without risking the offer entirely.

As a recruiter who’s coached corporate professionals navigate this exact moment, I’m here to tell you: you have more power than you think—if you use it wisely.

Let’s talk about what to do when the offer doesn’t quite hit the mark.

1. Pause Before Reacting

Your first instinct might be to fire off an emotional response—but don’t. Thank the employer for the offer, express appreciation, and ask for a day or two to review. This buys you time and signals professionalism.

Pro Tip: Avoid sharing your thoughts on the number right away. Give yourself space to strategize.

2. Do Your Research (Again)

Even if you researched salary ranges early on, now’s the time to dig deeper.

• What’s the average salary for this role in your city?

• How does your experience compare to others in similar roles?

• Are there any additional perks or benefits that offset the base salary?

Tools to use: Glassdoor, Payscale, or even speaking confidentially with a recruiter (hi 👋).

3. Decide What You Actually Need

Not every low offer is a dealbreaker. Get clear on your non-negotiables vs. nice-to-haves:

• Is the role a career accelerator?

• Will you be gaining high-value skills?

• Is work-life balance or flexibility part of the offer?

Once you know your bottom line, you're ready to negotiate from a grounded place.

4. Have the Conversation—Professionally

The key here is tone. You’re not demanding. You’re collaborating.

Here's a sample script:

“Thank you again for the offer. I’m genuinely excited about the opportunity and the team. Based on my experience in [X], and after doing some market comparisons, I was hoping for a base closer to [$X]. Is there flexibility to revisit the salary to better align with my expectations?”

Be brief, be confident, and don’t apologize for negotiating. You’re advocating for your worth.

5. Be Ready for Any Outcome

They might come back with a revised offer—or they might not budge.

If they can't move on salary, consider negotiating other aspects like:

• Signing bonus

• Additional vacation days

• Remote work flexibility or flexible hours

• Education or wellness stipends

• Early performance review cycles

Keep in mind, total package is worth more than the base salary alone.

You Can Negotiate Without Burning Bridges

Negotiation is not confrontation—it’s communication. And how you handle this conversation says a lot about your professionalism and confidence.

Remember: most employers expect some back-and-forth. The worst that can happen? They say no. But more often than not, you’ll walk away with more than you started with.

You got this!

Think you may need help prepping your own salary script or need guidance/practice before a big job move? Let’s chat. At Magnolia Recruitment, we help candidates get hired—and get paid what they deserve.

Find out more and book a session with one of our experienced and supportive Career Consultants below.

Book a Session